Tarnation
There are gothic tales of horror all around us, hidden in plain view. I had tastes of several growing up—something about my own, weird upbringing made me very freak-friendly—but I never grokked the way darkness goes hand in hand with light until I moved New York City in the mid-1980s.
You would meet people—in bars, mostly, but occasionally at parties, in bookstores, through friends of friends of friends—whose fabulousness you just knew was incredibly hard-won. I didn’t have a storybook childhood by any means, but there was (enough) money, stability and love to establish at least a foundation of normalcy to provide a reference point to the madness that followed. For example, my own overly-beautiful mother (as far as I know) was never subjected to repeated rounds of electroshock therapy, abandoned by my father when I was an infant or raped by a stranger in front of my eyes hours after we rolled into town on a Trailways bus.
All of these things happened to Jonathan Caouette, the writer-director-actor whose autobiographical documentary, Tarnation, took the film world by storm (four years ago, but more on that later.) Comprised of stills, film and video clips over at least 20 years, and originally edited entirely in iMovie, it’s a haunting, mesmerizing look at what one wrong turn (in this case, falling off of a house rooftop) can do to a delicate soul and everything that touches her.
It’s also a monumentally inspirational take on the power of the human spirit to prevail in the most horrific of circumstances. The film and video that Caouette pieces together to tell his story is clearly the film- and video-taking that kept him sane growing up in, to put it mildly, horrific circumstances. There are smidgins of film taken before even the very precocious filmmaker was ready to pick up a camera, but once those mini-digits were big enough to place “record”, it would seem young Caouette was at the ready and up to the task. Part of what’s so fascinating about the film is getting to see the artist in formation, on both sides of the camera (there’s one particularly compelling bit where he plays a woman in distress to the camera.)
Of course, even his impressive facility with the very simple tool that is iMovie was vastly enhanced by the soundtrack. Like El Mariachi some 15 years earlier, the film was made for peanuts ($218.32 of them!) and repackaged for substantially more. (Note to budding DIY filmmakers: if we can’t hear it right, we won’t be able to see it right.)
But who am I to quibble with the addition of some great songs and high-priced, Sunday-go-to-meetin’ sound editing? At its core, Tarnation is good, old-fashioned storytelling.
And I have never been one to turn down a good yarn…
xxx
c
- A great WIRED article on the making of Tarnation (for $218.32!!!)
- Tarnation: wikipedia entry
- Jonathan Caouette’s blog
Image of Jonathan Caouette and his beautiful mother from the film, via WIRED online.







4 Comments, Comment or Ping
Jon Haupt
148 reviews at Netflix, and decidedly, uh, mixed.
Predominant complaint was that the film was too
“self-absorbed.” This is familiar territory for me.
I don’t have much patience for indies, because the
indies people often don’t care what the audience thinks
or feels. Nothing wrong with that — but it’s like
a snake swallowing its tail.
I might rent it when I’m in a good mood.
:)
Dec 11th, 2007
Jay, writer MemberSpeed.com
It sounds like a movie to watch when in a strange mood. A chance to look at life from a different perspective. A perspective that is not dictated by anyone or anything. And also a chance to look at one’s own life and look for any evidence of strangeness that could perhaps be translated into something deeper.
Dec 19th, 2007
communicatrix
Jon - I could definitely see mixed reviews. It’s not a perfect film, by any means. Rather, it’s a harrowing story, notable for being told in an interesting way. I’d agree that the framing structure which features a lot of non-docu footage of Caouette getting yet more bad news about his mom was a bit hard to watch. But overall, some pretty standard great storytelling.
Jay - It did get me thinking about ways of sharing my own stories. I do it here on the blog, of course, but I’ve been playing with ideas of how to do it other ways.
Dec 19th, 2007
Jay's nemesis
Jay is a spammer. He is trying to improve his search rankings by spamming our blogs. Please delete his painfully anodyne comment. Search for his moniker elsewhere if you don’t believe me.
Mar 11th, 2008