Earnestness is the new irony
For once, I’m with Anil: April Fool’s Day sucks.
It’s rare that people get it right, coming up with a clever, playful joke that startles and teases, and then, with the reveal, delights. Most either fall flat, offend or have an effort-to-results ratio that reminds me of why I ran screaming in the night from the world of consumer advertising. It’s not bad enough that you commit to doing the stupid and bad; you must also commit precious resources towards the effort out of all reasonable proportion.
Plus, I’m a dyed-in-the-wool patsy—hopelessly earnest, relentlessly optimistic, easily hoodwinked. I was the one who gobbled up the four squares of Ex-Lax my cabin-mates told me was chocolate; a year or two earlier, I was the one who, when greeted at the bottom of the stairs leading to my friend’s family rec room by eight other friends yelling “Surprise!”—on my birthday—actually asked, “What?” (The answer: “It’s your birthday…Stupid.”)
For years, I hated my seemingly inborn earnestness. Haaaaaaated it. I wanted to be cool and sophisticated, smooth and worldly. Unfortunately for me, the raw material just wasn’t there. I was puny and inelegant and, let’s face it, built like a pound puppy: big eyes, tiny body, funny face, gigantic paws. But I was also blessed…or cursed…or blessed…with a medium-sized brain and a will of iron, and over the years (and far too often) I used them in service of my own nefarious and silly desires. If I couldn’t be elegant, I could be sarcastic. Oh, could I be sarcastic! I made a particular study of Oscar Wilde and Dorothy Parker, two profoundly funny-looking people who Made It Work, in the parlance of modern-day can-do maven, Tim Gunn, and honed my wit to a razor’s edge. I was even mean, sometimes. Okay…a lot. Okay—more than it’s comfortable to admit.
Somewhere along the line, it just got tiring, carrying all that crap around. To be organically funny is one thing; to work at it all the time is exhausting. It is also to live in fear: that you will fall flat on your face this next time, that you will be outed as a fraud, that you will fail and fall and be abandoned by all who said they loved you while you were entertaining them. Oy. Too, too much.
The setting down of my heavy load didn’t come all at once. It was more of a gradual denuding. Like when you flee the old country with all your silverware and rugs and paintings on your overladen cart, and you’re pulling it up that hill, and pulling it up that hill, and heaving things off so you can pull it up that damned hill, and finally you pluck one representative item from the heap—the scrap of cloth that didn’t make it onto the quilt but that has a story, or your beloved grandmother’s comb which is more missing than teeth—and let the rest of the rattletrap heap slide back down the hill for the Cossacks or gypsies to plunder. That amazing, liberating moment when you get that it’s really love that’s the thing, not things.
Of course, I still like words. And I still really like stringing words together to make people laugh. I’m starting to realize, though, that I really, really like stringing the words together to make people laugh so they’ll relax, or laugh so they’ll let down their guard, or laugh so they’ll take a second look at an idea or a thought or a really good cause. Laughter disarms people, yes, but I don’t want to disarm anyone so they’re unprotected and squashable, but rather, to temporarily jam the force field and get some interesting interaction happening.
To get the do-gooders hooked up with the want-to-fund-do-gooder-ers. To get the do-gooders doing different kinds of good to lighten up and find more ways each other is alike than different. To keep the do-gooders doing good, or, if they’d do it anyway, to throw a little happy their way to make the job more pleasant. We each of us have our place.
My place might be on the ground, butt up in the air, a “Kick Me, Hard” sign affixed to the soft and fleshy part. So be it.
Some of us are born elegant; some of us are born clowns. You can fight it or you can work with it. Do the former, and while you may climb the ladder of fortune and fame, you’ll also be resigned to a life of struggle and worry and looking over your shoulder.
Do the latter and you’re nobody’s fool.
Even if you will suffer a sore ass from time to time…
xxx
c
Image by phitar via Flickr, used under a Creative Commons license.
TOPICS: change, fear, humor, sarcasm.








16 Comments, Comment or Ping
hoohash
Great post.
I just stumbled upon your blog and have been reading with great interest. I have recently come to realize that I need to be more comfortable with being myself. Sounds simple and cliche, but this is something I struggle with. I have created my own spokesperson and he has gotten out of control. Slowly, I am rediscovering and accepting the long buried “me” and I like what I see.
Happy April Fool’s Day!
Apr 1st, 2008
Dave G
Yes! I’m sick of April Fools Day too. Maybe it’s just the pressure of coming up with something good every. single. year. It’s so forced sometimes.
Loved the personal rumination as well. Your thoughts on irony are very similar to my own. Growing up, I remember studying the comedians of the day, just so I could be like them. So much pressure. Too much.
Apr 1st, 2008
Sally J. (Practical Archivist)
“I’m starting to realize, though, that I really, really like stringing the words together to make people laugh so they’ll relax, or laugh so they’ll let down their guard, or laugh so they’ll take a second look at an idea or a thought or a really good cause.”
You do this so, so so well. It’s a wonderful gift and I’m glad you’re using it for good.
Apr 1st, 2008
communicatrix
Hoohash – God bless (seeming) randomness, eh? I’m glad you made it. And I think describing it as creating your own spokesperson who has gotten out of control means you’re going to be able to manifest all the change you want.
Welcome!
Dave G – Wow. I guess I should count my blessings that it never occurred to me to actually come up with stuff. I was mostly concerned about getting hoodwinked and made to look stupid. I felt stupid enough most of the time with no help from anyone.
Apr 1st, 2008
Micah Erskine
Thank you!
I have never had the “edge” necessary to plan and execute “hilarious” April 1st hijinks and I am just as glad to let the day pass unacknowledged.
I too stumbled across your blog today (thanks to Twitter and Merlin Mann) and was delighted to read this post. I relate strongly to your experience of setting down your heavy load – in my case of certain mis-aligned career expectations – and also like to think that my talent and career may well lie in getting fractious groups communicate and work together a little more effectively.
So, congratulations on the lightened load and spirit and thank you for being hopelessly earnest and relentlessly optimistic!
Apr 1st, 2008
communicatrix
You are so welcome! Thank you for speaking up. Seriously. This is feeling a little like the end of Revenge of the Nerds, when slowly all the losers lay down their band instruments and rise up against their non-nerd oppressors.
I think I may have to get some damned tshirts printed up. Hopelessly earnest relentless optimists, unite!
Apr 1st, 2008
Pamela Slim
You are such a great freaking writer! Damn. Love it.
And I agree — April Fool’s never worked for me either.
Keep on whatever you are doing, because it is glorious.
Apr 1st, 2008
Bon
My least favorite day of the year. I said so, just 22 some-odd hours ago, when bracing myself for a full day of being “on guard” because I always, always, always fall for something–because I so completely believe everyone. Always.
So far, pretty good this year. I haven’t gotten suckered in on anything (mostly by staying on guard all damn day) and it’s almost over.
But, man, that being on guard is exhausting.
I’ll take one of those T-shirts in X-L, please.
Apr 1st, 2008
Pamela Slim
Dang, I wrote this comment before and for some reason it didn’t show up.
Could it be April Fools on me? Yikes!
What I said was …
You are a brilliant writer. A true gem. Gives me the chills.
Whatever you are doing, do more of it! Love it!
Apr 1st, 2008
communicatrix
Pam! and again, Pam! – They did both show up, and I’ll be damned if I’m removing either, since (a) they have such super-nice compliments and (b) if they don’t illustrate my frustration w/ April Fool’s Day in a meta-way better than I ever could w/ plain old words, well, I don’t know what could.
For the record–mostly, for any other future potential commentors reading this–I have this problem, too, when I leave a comment. It’s something about the way the browser caches the site, and I’m not sure if it’s the browser or the site. It *seems* to happen in different browsers, which leads me to believe it’s the site. Which, now that I”ve followed the logic tree to the tippy top, I guess I need to put on my to-do list for a developer.
So a third thanks, for that!
Bon – Definitely the down side of relentless optimism and hopeless earnestness. But I’ll take ‘em. And think about those tees…
Apr 2nd, 2008
claire
“I’m starting to realize, though, that I really, really like stringing the words together to make people laugh so they’ll relax, or laugh so they’ll let down their guard, or laugh so they’ll take a second look at an idea or a thought or a really good cause.”
I really like to make people laugh too, however my humor is somewhat askew for most. Hadn’t really considered the “so they’ll…” part of it. I like yours a whole lot.
Apr 2nd, 2008
communicatrix
Thanks! FWIW, I’m most definitely not everyone’s cup of tea. I finally (mostly) got over it, and just direct my stuff and attention to the people whose cuppa I am.
Apr 2nd, 2008
david
As a son of immigrants, I’m riddled with inborn earnestness.
I’ve got a love-hate relationship with my career as an engineer. It’s a tedious line of work. At some point, I realized that if I walk around *acting* earnest (I mean *really* earnest), though I really could careless – it somehow allowed me to get through my days easier.
Interesting post. Props.
Apr 2nd, 2008
Angie
Much to my chagrin, I was played yesterday! I told myself I wouldn’t fall for any jokes but when my boss is the only playing me…….
“To get the do-gooders hooked up with the want-to-fund-do-gooder-ers. To get the do-gooders doing different kinds of good to lighten up and find more ways each other is alike than different. To keep the do-gooders doing good, or, if they’d do it anyway, to throw a little happy their way to make the job more pleasant. We each of us have our place.”
Am I the only one who had to read that more than once! Love it C…..
Apr 2nd, 2008
communicatrix
David – You know, until tonight, I would have had no idea what you meant. But today, I had occasion to be very earnest–perhaps more earnest than I am normally. Because I wasn’t particularly into the proposition at hand. But I did it, and as I did, I felt like it helped: helped me get through it, helped the other party feel heard/seen.
Thanks for the comment, and the thumbs-up.
Angie – *I* had to read it twice. And I wrote it!
Apr 2nd, 2008
Anil
“For once”?! Am I really wrong that often? Hrm.
Apr 4th, 2008